2023

Opera House

Share this

Introduction

On 9 October 2023, two days after the Hamas attack on Israel, the Sydney Opera House was lit blue and white in solidarity with Israel and with those killed and taken hostage in the attack.

A pro-Palestinian rally assembled at Sydney Town Hall and marched through the CBD to the Opera House. Hundreds of protesters gathered on the forecourt while the sails were lit in the colours of the Israeli flag.

Flares and fireworks were set off, Palestinian flags were displayed and an Israeli flag was burned. Among the chants recorded at the demonstration were "f--- the Jews", "Where's the Jews?", "f--- Israel" and other anti-Israel slogans.

Video circulated after the protest with subtitles claiming demonstrators had chanted "gas the Jews." The claim was widely reported by Australian and international media and was repeated in political debate.

NSW Police set up Strike Force Mealing to investigate offences committed during the protest. It gathered extensive audio and video recordings and commissioned specialist acoustic and phonetic analysis of the disputed footage.

In February 2024, NSW Police announced that the forensic examination had found no evidence that "gas the Jews" had been chanted in the recordings examined. The expert concluded with "overwhelming certainty" that the disputed phrase was "Where's the Jews?"

Police said this did not mean the demonstration had been free of antisemitic or offensive conduct. Other offensive language was captured in recordings of the protest.

Government Response

The NSW Government, led by Premier Chris Minns, decided to light the Opera House as an expression of solidarity with Israel after the 7 October attack.

Police knew a pro-Palestinian demonstration was planned, and that protesters intended to travel from Town Hall to the Opera House.

The march was not authorised. Police Minister Yasmin Catley said the organisers "did not fill out the necessary paperwork" and that police "did not approve the march": "There was no Form 1 for this event." The Form 1 process, she said, "generally takes about a week to complete." Assistant Commissioner Tony Cooke said police "became aware of the rally on Sunday", the day before, and that it was "considered the best option for police" to "manage the movement of those people from Sydney Town Hall to the Opera House", adding it was "not the police's position to stop protests" (ABC News, 10 October 2023).

Police advised members of Sydney's Jewish community not to go to the Opera House because of concerns for their safety. One Jewish man carrying an Israeli flag who approached the demonstration was removed by police to prevent a breach of the peace and for his own protection. He was released without further action.

The Opera House had been lit in solidarity with Israel and the Jewish community, yet members of that community were advised not to go there.

Minns at first defended the police's operational decisions on public-safety grounds.

Documents later produced to the NSW Parliament showed that senior police had warned before the demonstration that protesters converging on the Opera House could escalate existing tensions. On 25 October 2023, Minns acknowledged that his government had made a "mistake" by not acting on those warnings.

Strike Force Mealing was set up to identify, investigate and prosecute criminal offences arising from the 9 October protest.

The events became part of a wider debate over whether NSW laws gave police enough power to respond to threatening or hateful conduct at demonstrations. The policing, the treatment of Jewish Australians who tried to approach the site, the chants and the official response continued to be examined through parliamentary processes.

In 2026, the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion made the events of 9 October 2023 a specific focus of its hearing into protests and policing, examining hateful conduct in protest settings and whether policing responses to antisemitic conduct could be improved.

Summary

On 9 October 2023, two days after the Hamas attack on Israel, the NSW Government lit the Sydney Opera House in the colours of Israel. A pro-Palestinian demonstration marched to the forecourt. Antisemitic language was recorded, an Israeli flag was burned and flares were set off. Police had advised members of Sydney's Jewish community not to attend.

The widely circulated claim that protesters chanted "gas the Jews" was not substantiated by the NSW Police forensic investigation. Expert analysis found the disputed recording contained the words "Where's the Jews?" Other antisemitic and offensive language at the demonstration was separately documented.

Premier Chris Minns later acknowledged that failing to act on police warnings about the protest had been a mistake.

Australia's Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism later described the protest as a "critical turning point" in the escalation of antisemitism in New South Wales, and said it "set the tenor" for the hateful and intimidatory activity that followed.

The Executive Council of Australian Jewry recorded 2,062 anti-Jewish incidents between October 2023 and September 2024, compared with 495 in the previous twelve-month reporting period.

In 2026 the events were a specific focus of the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion's examination of protests, hateful conduct and policing.

You be the judge.

Leave a comment