2004

Jack Roche

Share this

Introduction

Jack Roche, a Muslim convert, was arrested on 18 November 2002, about five weeks after the Bali bombing. His case concerned a plot that was disrupted, not an attack that took place.

In the Perth District Court in May 2004, Roche was tried for conspiring to bomb the Israeli embassy in Canberra. He pleaded not guilty at the start. On the tenth day of the trial he changed his plea to guilty, admitting he had conspired with al-Qaeda and Jemaah Islamiyah to bomb the embassy.

On 1 June 2004 Judge Paul Healy sentenced him to nine years' imprisonment, backdated to his arrest, with a non-parole period of about four and a half years. He was released on 17 May 2007.

What Roche told police

Much of what the court heard about how the plot came together came from taped police interviews with Roche, which were played in court. That material was his own account, presented as evidence, rather than judicial findings.

In those interviews he said he travelled to Afghanistan in March 2000, met Osama bin Laden, underwent explosives training, and agreed to identify US and Jewish targets in Australia. He said Hambali, the Jemaah Islamiyah operations chief, sent him to Pakistan and Afghanistan and gave him about $8,000 to fund the attacks. Notes in evidence referred to identifying the Israeli embassy and a Jewish businessman as targets.

The court was told the plot was called off on the orders of the Indonesian cleric Abu Bakar Bashir. That was Roche's account; Bashir has denied involvement in Jemaah Islamiyah.

Government Response

The prosecution followed an ASIO and police investigation into Jemaah Islamiyah activity in Australia after the Bali bombing.

Judge Healy was reported as saying sentencing was difficult because there were no precedents. He was also reported as saying the plot had every chance of being carried out had Roche not decided that enough was enough, and that the sentence had to act as a strong deterrent. He said he would have imposed 12 years but reduced the sentence because of information Roche gave to federal authorities. The ABC reported that Roche's cooperation may have assisted in the arrests of Hambali and another senior al-Qaeda figure.

Summary

The case came before an Australian court after the Bali bombing had killed 88 Australians. Roche pleaded guilty to conspiring with al-Qaeda and Jemaah Islamiyah to bomb the Israeli embassy in Canberra, and was sentenced to nine years.

During the trial the court also heard notebook evidence referring to a meeting with Hambali at which "the possibility of doing something in Sydney during the Olympic Games was discussed". This is evidence that such an action was discussed, but the conviction was for the embassy conspiracy only.

You be the judge.

Leave a comment